Isis ([info]swtfxofaddrm) wrote in [info]boulder_co,

Organic Standards are being attacked

Hi. This is x-posted and I did copy and paste from a website so it is a bit dense. Please go to the website and sign the petition!!!


"The Organic Consumers Association (OCA) needs your immediate help to stop Congress and the Bush administration from seriously degrading organic standards. After 35 years of hard work, the U.S. organic community has built up a multi-billion dollar alternative to industrial agriculture, based upon strict organic standards and organic community control over modification to these standards.

Now, large corporations such as Kraft & Dean Foods--aided and abetted by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), are moving to lower organic standards by allowing a Bush appointee to create a list of synthetic ingredients that would be allowed organic production. Even worse these proposed regulatory changes will reduce future public discussion and input and take away the National Organic Standards Board's (NOSB) traditional lead jurisdiction in setting standards. What this means, in blunt terms. is that USDA bureaucrats and industry lobbyists, not consumers, will now have more control over what can go into organic foods and products.

This week, acting in haste and near-total secrecy, the U.S. Senate will vote on a "rider" to the 2006 Agriculture Appropriations Bill that will reduce control over organic standards from the National Standards Board and put this control in the hands of federal bureaucrats in the USDA (remember the USDA proposal in 1997-98 that said that genetic engineering, toxic sludge, and food irradiation would be OK on organic farms, or USDA suggestions in 2004 that heretofore banned pesticides, hormones, tainted feeds, and animal drugs would be OK?).

For the past week in Washington, OCA has been urging members of the Senate not to reopen and subvert the federal statute that governs U.S. Organic standards (the Organic Food Production Act - OFPA), but rather to let the organic community and the National Organic Standards resolve our differences over issues like synthetics and animal feed internally, and then proceed to a open public comment period. Unfortunately most Senators seem to be listening to industry lobbyists more closely than to us. We need to raise our voices.

In the past, grassroots mobilization and mass pressure by organic consumers have been able to stop the USDA and Congress from degrading organic standards. This time Washington insiders tell us that the "fix is is already in." So we must take decisive action now. We need you to call your U.S. Senators today. We need you to sign the following petition and send it to everyone you know. We also desperately need funds to head off this attack in the weeks and months to come. Thank you for your support. Together we will take back citizen control over organic standards and preserve organic integrity.

Take action here:
http://www.demaction.org/dia/organizations/oca/campaign.jsp?campaign_KEY=1242 "

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 8 comments

[info]graey42

September 24 2005, 04:54:43 UTC 6 years ago

USDA bureaucrats and industry lobbyists, not consumers, will now have more control over what can go into organic foods and products.


You're complaining that the USDA is loosening regulations and that consumers are losing control? The more control the federal government has, the less control consumers and producers have. Vote to loosen or abolish government regulation if you want to regain control over what you eat and buy.

[info]swtfxofaddrm

September 24 2005, 14:43:09 UTC 6 years ago

think you might misunderstand. I think that that sentance was worded poorly, and I didn't write it (so it is possible I am misunderstanding too).

If the USDA loosens the organic standard (for example, allowing sythetic ingredients) than comsumers will no longer have control over what they are putting into their body. The approved organic products will no longer be held to the standard we appreciate and trust. By buying organic, regulated products, I do have control over what I eat and buy (so I would never want to vote to abolish the regulation).

[info]graey42

September 24 2005, 15:38:48 UTC 6 years ago

Consumers can control what they put into their bodies by buying products from businesses that meet the standards consumers want. Businesses will meet or ignore standards based on how much business they want to lose or not. It works out fine the way it is, and does not require government regulation to function. I am especially appalled at the part about giving handouts to farmers so they can meet these restrictions. Let people buy and sell what they want. It's supposed to be a free country.


I advocate not supporting this movement.

[info]477150n

September 24 2005, 16:55:38 UTC 6 years ago

You make a good point. However, as a consumer, I don't have the time or energy to investigate each company whose food I wish to buy and see if it meets my standards or not. Therefore, I rely on the government to perform this function. Right now, I know that if I see the "USDA Organic" logo on a food item, its production has met certain standards which match mine. If those standards are changed so they no longer match mine (and many other consumers') then the government has not given me enough information to make an informed choice.

I would hazard to guess, however, that you are ideologically a "small government" person. You would probably rather that the government stay out of the business of putting the "USDA Organic" logo on the food in the first place. I respect that point of view. In fact, things worked pretty well when private companies would assure consumers that the food lived up to certain standards. However, I do prefer the USDA oversight of organic standards.

[info]twoser

September 24 2005, 20:03:04 UTC 6 years ago

The only way consumers can control what they put in their bodies is to have accurate labeling. Therefore, the definition of organic is vital to this truth in advertising. If you are someone who does not care whether or not your food is organic, then this does not effect you. The labeling would not require someone to sell organic food, it only regulates what standards and definitions that allow something to be labeled as 'Organic'.

Mary

[info]swtfxofaddrm

September 25 2005, 00:34:27 UTC 6 years ago

Thank you Mary.

[info]graey42

September 25 2005, 03:14:26 UTC 6 years ago

I'm sorry. I just don't feel that this is the job of the government. This is better left to voluntary compliance, or a non-government regulating body.

At any rate, I've stated my opinion and don't want to argue til I'm blue in the face, so I'll shut up.

[info]twoser

September 28 2005, 21:46:41 UTC 6 years ago

It is voluntary compliance. Glad to see we agree.
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…